Best payroll software, compared
Quick verdict
As of 2026-09-27, we're still verifying enough data to name a best-overall pick for payroll software — the cheapest tool we compare today is Gusto at $35/mo, a price fact, not a recommendation. 0 of the 4 tools on this page offer a free plan.
ToolFit may earn a commission from some links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.
All 4 payroll software, compared
Prices checked| Tool | Free plan | Starts at | Priced options | Best for | Visit site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gusto | ✗ | $35/mo | 4 | small business solopreneurs & beginners | Visit site → |
| SurePayroll | ✗ | $39/mo | 1 | small business solopreneurs & beginners | Visit site → |
| OnPay | ✗ | $49/mo | 1 | small business restaurants nonprofits | Visit site → |
| Justworks | ✗ | $50/mo | 1 | small business | Visit site → |
Across the 4 payroll software we track, entry prices range from $35/mo to $50/mo, with a median of $44/mo. 0 of 4 payroll software include a free plan.
Sources: gusto.com/product/pricing, verified · surepayroll.com/pricing, verified · onpay.com/payroll/software/accountants/pricing, verified · justworks.com/pricing, verified
Get notified when prices change
We track payroll software pricing daily. Get a weekly email roundup of price changes — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Go deeper on payroll software
Every comparison, pricing guide, and head-to-head we maintain — each built from the same dated dataset as the table above.
Alternatives guides
- Gusto alternatives
- SurePayroll alternatives
- OnPay alternatives
- Justworks alternatives